How to Gather Evidence for Your Hays County Property Tax Protest

Filing a protest against your property tax appraisal in Hays County is a powerful way to ensure you're not overpaying—but success depends heavily on the quality of your evidence. With rapid development and shifting valuations across San Marcos, Kyle, Buda, and surrounding areas, it’s crucial to present compelling, accurate, and locally relevant data.

Why Evidence Matters

The Hays Central Appraisal District (HCAD) uses mass appraisal techniques, which may overlook the specifics of your property. Without strong evidence, your protest is unlikely to sway the district or the Appraisal Review Board (ARB).

Effective evidence supports your claim that your property’s appraised value is higher than what it would reasonably sell for on the open market as of January 1 of the tax year.

Types of Evidence That Strengthen Your Protest

1. Comparable Sales (Comps)

Find 3–5 recently sold homes in your neighborhood that are:

• Similar in square footage, age, and layout
• Sold before January 1 of the appraisal year
• In the same school district or subdivision (if possible)

Use MLS data, Realtor reports, or trusted online platforms. Highlight any adjustments needed (e.g., if the comp had a pool and your home does not).

2. Photos of Your Property’s Condition

Visuals speak volumes. Take current photos of any:

• Roof damage
• Cracks in foundation or walls
• Old HVAC units or appliances
• Outdated kitchens/bathrooms

This is especially helpful if HCAD used comps from newly renovated or modern homes.

3. Repair Estimates or Contractor Reports

If you’ve gotten quotes for repairs or renovations, include them. These reports help prove your property is not in the same condition as higher-value comps.

4. Independent Appraisals

A third-party appraisal can serve as strong, professional validation of your argument. While there is a cost involved, it can pay off if your savings outweigh the expense.

5. Property Records and Documentation

Pull official property records and past appraisal notices to ensure all facts are accurate—like square footage, number of bathrooms, year built, etc. Any discrepancy can form the basis of your protest.

Local Context Is Key in Hays County

Each city within Hays County is experiencing unique trends. For example:

• San Marcos may see inflated values from student housing developments near Texas State University.
• Kyle and Buda are rapidly growing but contain pockets of older homes that shouldn't be compared to new subdivisions.

By tailoring your evidence to reflect these nuances, your protest becomes far more compelling.

How Ballard Property Tax Protest Supports You

We go beyond generic advice by:

• Pulling localized, relevant comps from within Hays County
• Conducting detailed property evaluations
• Building a custom protest strategy for your specific situation

We know what the Appraisal Review Board looks for—and how to present your case for maximum impact.

Take the First Step Today

Gathering the right evidence is the foundation of a successful property tax protest. Don’t leave your appraisal unchallenged—especially in a rapidly changing market like Hays County.

Sign Up with Ballard Property Tax Protest today and let us help you build a strong case and reduce your property tax bill.

‍